Honestly, you’re not alone! I’ve watched my supposedly discerning fluffball turn her nose up at artisanal, single-source quail in favor of kibble that looks like packing peanuts. The reality is, cats can love the “fast food” stuff—it’s palatable, consistent, and hits all the right flavors for them. Purina One isn’t haute cuisine, but it’s not trash either; it does meet AAFCO standards and tends to have decent protein vs. filler compared to some other brands.
What matters is how your cat’s thriving: good coat, bright eyes, energy, and less hairball chaos? I’ll take it. Sometimes their taste buds just don’t care about our human aspirations for them! If she’s happy and healthy, save the stress (and the gourmet food money). Just keep an eye on weight, hydration, and maybe toss her some wet food or treats now and then for variety—world domination plots aside.